Earning money online in Pakistan without any initial investment is possible, but it may require time, effort, and skills. Here are some legitimate ways to make money online without spending any money upfront:

Freelancing: If you have skills in writing, graphic design, web development, digital marketing, or any other field, you can offer your services on freelancing platforms like Upwork, Freelancer, Fiverr, or PeoplePerHour. Clients from around the world often hire freelancers from Pakistan. Earn Money With Shafqat 

Content Creation: You can create content on platforms like YouTube, TikTok, or a blog. Once you have a substantial following, you can monetize your content through ads, sponsorships, and affiliate marketing.

Online Tutoring: If you are knowledgeable in a particular subject, you can offer online tutoring services. Websites like Chegg Tutors or WizIQ can connect you with students seeking help.

Online Surveys and Market Research: Several websites and apps, such as Swagbucks, Vindale Research, and Survey Junkie, pay users for participating in surveys, watching videos, or providing feedback.

Affiliate Marketing: Promote products or services from various companies and earn a commission on each sale made through your affiliate links. You can join affiliate programs offered by Amazon, ClickBank, or local e-commerce stores.

Content Writing: If you're a good writer, you can contribute articles to platforms like HubPages or Medium, which allow you to earn money based on the number of views and engagement your content receives.

Online Marketplaces: You can sell products online through platforms like Daraz.pk, Olx, or PakWheels, where you can create listings for items you want to sell.

Virtual Assistance: Offer administrative or technical support to businesses and entrepreneurs online. Websites like Upwork and Freelancer often have job listings for virtual assistants.

Online Gaming and Streaming: If you're skilled in video games, you can stream your gameplay on platforms like Twitch and YouTube Gaming. You can earn money through ads, donations, and sponsorships.

Remote Work: Look for remote job opportunities on websites like We Work Remotely, Remote.co, and Indeed. Many companies hire remote workers for various positions, including customer support, data entry, and programming.

Online Writing Contests: Participate in writing contests and competitions that offer cash prizes. Websites like Writing.com and FanStory.com often host such events.

Micro-Tasking: Platforms like Amazon Mechanical Turk and Clickworker allow you to complete small tasks for pay, such as data entry or content moderation.

Remember that while these methods can help you earn money online without an upfront investment, they may not provide instant or substantial income. Building a reliable online income often takes time and dedication. Be cautious of scams and fraudulent schemes, and always do thorough research before getting involved in any online money-making opportunity.