While technically located on the edge    Best butter chicken Brooklyn   of Brooklyn in the Lower East Side, The MasalaWala is a must-visit for butter chicken aficionados. Known for its authentic Indian cuisine, this restaurant offers a butter chicken dish that is both rich and flavorful. The sauce is a harmonious blend of tomatoes, cream, and a mix of spices that create a delightful depth of flavor. The chicken is tender and juicy, having been marinated and cooked to perfection. The MasalaWala’s butter chicken is a testament to traditional Indian cooking, and it’s definitely worth the short trip from Brooklyn.

2. ** Jaiya Thai - Bay Ridge

Jaiya Thai, although primarily a Thai restaurant, offers a unique fusion twist on butter chicken. The restaurant’s version blends traditional Indian spices with Thai ingredients, creating a distinct flavor profile that’s both creamy and tangy. The chicken is cooked in a flavorful sauce that incorporates coconut milk and lemongrass, adding an unexpected but delightful twist. Jaiya Thai’s butter chicken is a great choice for those looking to explore a fusion of cuisines while enjoying a comforting classic.

3. ** Sakura - Williamsburg

Sakura, known for its sushi and Japanese fare, offers an unexpected but delightful butter chicken option. The restaurant’s take on the dish incorporates Japanese elements, such as a subtle miso flavor, into the traditional Indian recipe. The result is a butter chicken that’s both familiar and refreshingly different. Sakura’s butter chicken is a great example of how culinary boundaries can be blurred to create something truly unique. For a new spin on an old favorite, Sakura is a fantastic choice.

4. ** The Finch - Ridgewood

The Finch is a Michelin-starred restaurant that offers a contemporary take on classic dishes, including butter chicken. Here, the dish is elevated with modern techniques and high-quality ingredients. The butter chicken at The Finch is known for its perfectly balanced flavors, with a sauce that is both creamy and slightly spicy. The chicken is cooked to a tender perfection, and the dish is often served with artisanal naan bread or fragrant basmati rice. The Finch provides a fine dining experience that reimagines traditional butter chicken in an elegant setting.

5. ** Tandoori Hut - Park Slope

Tandoori Hut is a local favorite in Park Slope, known for its authentic Indian flavors and friendly atmosphere. The butter chicken here is a standout, featuring a rich, creamy sauce with a perfect blend of spices. The chicken is marinated and cooked in a tandoor, adding a smoky depth to the dish. Tandoori Hut’s butter chicken is often praised for its consistency and quality, making it a reliable choice for those craving traditional Indian cuisine in Brooklyn.

6. ** Banares - Prospect Lefferts Gardens

Banares offers a range of Indian dishes, but its butter chicken is particularly noteworthy. The restaurant’s version of the dish features a velvety tomato-based sauce with just the right amount of spice. The chicken is tender and well-seasoned, and the dish is served with freshly made naan or rice. Banares is known for its welcoming atmosphere and consistently high-quality food, making it a great spot for enjoying a comforting bowl of butter chicken.

7. ** Curry Heights - Flatbush

Curry Heights is a popular choice in Flatbush for its flavorful and authentic Indian dishes. The butter chicken here is a highlight, with a creamy, tomato-based sauce that’s rich and satisfying. The chicken is cooked to perfection, and the dish is complemented by a variety of Indian breads and rice. Curry Heights is known for its generous portions and reasonable prices, making it a great option for a hearty and delicious meal.

Conclusion

Brooklyn’s vibrant food scene offers an impressive array of options for butter chicken enthusiasts. From traditional Indian fare to innovative fusions, the borough’s restaurants serve up this beloved dish in a variety of delightful ways. Whether you’re a purist or an adventurous eater, Brooklyn’s best butter chicken spots are sure to satisfy your cravings and provide a memorable dining experience.